.
Feedback

Parents Talk: School Lunch vs. Lunch Box

It's a mixed brown bag when it comes to what kids should eat in school.

School lunch can pose a problem for many parents.

Should you send a lunch from home, or should your kids eat school lunch?  

Many parents go with the school lunch program because it provides variety and is, for the most part, both easier and cheaper. Some parents believe that they can send a more nutritious lunch from home. And for picky eaters or children with dietary concerns, a bagged lunch might be the answer.


According to a university-sponsored study done on the subject in 2010, more than one in three middle school students who regularly eat school lunches are obese or overweight. The research suggests that efforts to provide healthier choices on school lunch menus still have a long way to go. But if I recall from my days in middle school, my parent-funded lunch money meant for the hot lunch line could just as easily have paid for a chocolate chip cookie the size of my head or a basket of French fries from a la carte.

Although things have improved in the area of nutrition since my school days, your child may choose to trade his or her salad for a brownie on a daily basis anyway. Of course, always helpful are on-going discussions with your child about nutrition and demonstrations of a healthy lifestyle set by your own example.

Last spring, a principal at a school in Chicago decided that all children, except for those with severe allergies, would eat school lunch and school lunch alone. The idea was to protect children from their own unhealthy food choices.

While we still have the opportunity to make the decision for ourselves, parents must decide what kind of lunch is best for their children.

So, do you include a lunch box or cash for lunch in your kids' backpacks? Why?

Tell us in comments.

Heather G September 7, 2011 at 07:55 pm
My daughter prefers lunch from home. Every great once in a while she'll see something on the menu that she's intrigued by, but in the end she'd rather have her sandwich and lowfat cheese stick.
Claire Killian September 7, 2011 at 08:00 pm
My son would always eat a bag lunch...unless it was pizza day. It wasn't until he was in middle school that he ate school lunch. His big choice of the day was white or chocolate milk! He always chose to eat healthy.
Lana Slavitt September 7, 2011 at 09:09 pm
My oldest son always brought a packed lunch in elementary school. By choice. Now he attends a private middle school where the kids are not allowed to bring lunch from home. My youngest brings a zero-waste packed lunch too - that is, unless it is Tuesday (pizza day). While school lunches have come a long way, there is still plenty of room to improve (why is chocolate milk even an option?), and I'm grateful that they both prefer/preferred the healthy lunches we make in the morning at home.
Suzanne Huss September 8, 2011 at 11:41 am
I always had my kids eat the school lunches and they are not picky eaters. The Hopkins lunch program is great. They have so many choices for the kids. There is always something they like. Take a look at the lunch menu. A lot different than when I went to school. http://www.hopkinsschools.org/sites/default/files/September_2011_elementary_lunch_and_breakfast_5_2.pdf
David F September 8, 2011 at 12:15 pm
Many school districts including LA have removed chocotate milk from their school lunch programs. Edina feels since the USDA recommends sugared milks it is ok. Bad choice.
Most school lunch programs including Edina include too many unhealthy foods and my children bring bag lunches from home.
Rita May 1, 2012 at 04:14 pm
Is chocolate milk REALLY that bad? I remember in my school days I picked chocolate milk because I couldn't stand the taste of the school's white milk. I really wish they had other options besides milk like water, because drinking the milk always made me nervous. There were some days when it tasted off or when there were lumps in it and it was enough to put me off of drinking it, but unfortunately it was the only option and I would be thirsty if I didn't drink it. I'm not saying that I want soda for the kids, but bottled water would be a nice alternative.
Caitlin Burgess (Editor) May 1, 2012 at 05:33 pm
The milk really had lumps in it!?
David F May 1, 2012 at 06:12 pm
Nothing wrong with water but if the kids are learning anything about sustainability water in bottles is not an option. The supply chain for dairy products has improved dramatically over the years and it is highly unlikely (not impossible) for milk to be spoiled in the schools. Chocolate milk, like soda, contains high amounts of sugar which are unnecessary and has been pointed out can lead to obesity. The idea of school lunch program was started because the US military was finding young recruits were malnourished and now the US military is finding most young US children are obese. It is good to see so many parents involved in helping their children make the right dietary decisions but too many children make the bad choices as mentioned that maybe do not get the same guidance.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Minnetonka Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Heyitsme May 17, 2013 at 07:23 pm
Oh, an her dad works for Cargill, IT staff. And stop throwing out bad science regarding theRead More agricultural industry. Professionals again do NOT arbitrarily throw out these diagnosies. It was not in the food she ate. We tried food elimination/avoidance before the medication. I ate healthy while pregnant and her sister certainly doesn't have ADHD. Instead she has mild dyslexia. I guess my asthma was not genetic either. All these things are genetic, not environmentally caused. Triggers can be environmental.
Heyitsme May 17, 2013 at 07:31 pm
Can you use a mini trampoline in school? Subject your student to be called in class for acting up?Read More Schools expect the student to sit and listen. So do the best for your child and give him a helping hand if possible. I am not advocating medication unless possible...it just ticks me off that you have some people that think its just a lazy label handed out by doctors.
Heyitsme May 17, 2013 at 07:34 pm
MINE doesn't sell her medication. One it's a felony and two she NEEDS to take her medication.Read More The bottle doesn't leave the house and is locked up. It is very difficult to get a controlled substance like the ADHD medication refilled before the current prescription is scheduled to run out of pills. Too many of the "lost" refill requests can result in an investigation. She lost her pills once (only a nine doses of pills left) and I had to sign a waiver stating that the prescription was truly lost.
KCLEGACYMEDIA May 7, 2013 at 12:40 am
We just made an inforgraphic that outlines the staggering cost of prom for 2013. Check it out here:Read More http://www.kclegacypress.com/2013/05/06/closer-look-at-cost-of-prom/
Scott May 9, 2013 at 10:34 pm
Hi Mike -- It is possible to have liberal ideals and spend wisely. Sheri's son got a free tux on theRead More back of his hardworking friends? Sounds like communism to me! In all seriousness, I applaud Sheri for raising a sensible son, and I deplore Mike B.'s parents for raising him to blame a political party for all shortcomings in a society.
Mike B. May 9, 2013 at 10:39 pm
Scott, there is no such thing as "liberal ideals." Liberals are pro-abortion, pro-taxingRead More people to death, pro-homosexual marriage, pro-kicking God out of the classroom.... these are not "ideals." These are evil beliefs.