.
Feedback

How Young Is Too Young For Competition?

Recent baby races have me wondering if pitting our children against each other is a healthy decision.

The cities of Maple Grove and Lakeville recently held festivals. ; in Maple Grove, it was . Each town hosted a or as part of the festivities.

The Star Tribune recently covered a baby race during Kaposia Days in South St. Paul.

Let's be honest, a crowd of crawling babies is pretty much the cutest thing you'll ever see. So it's understandable why parents show up and why photographers click away. But is it healthy?

I seriously doubt the babies are getting anything from it, except maybe a ribbon to nibble on. So clearly the competition is for the parents. A win brings bragging rights, and then there's all that adorableness (Yes, that's actually a word.).

I fear baby competitions are part of a more pervasive trend of parents comparing milestones to prove their offspring are superior to others. An article on Parents.com says there are no report cards before school, so parents need to know if their children are reaching benchmarks when they should. The story also suggests that parents may compare their children to others out of fear: A child who is behind the curve could have a developmental disorder, such as autism.

If I had a child, I doubt I'd bring him or her to a crawling race. Someone would have to convince me that there was something my baby would get out of the experience, beyond scraped knees.

That's my opinion, but what do you think? Are baby or toddler competitions healthy? Explain your vote in the comments below.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Minnetonka Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Anna Schier July 20, 2012 at 05:10 am
I don't necessarily think that they're healthy or unhealthy. If the children competing are infants or young toddlers, they likely have no conception that a competition is even happening.
However, I do think that for older toddlers and preschoolers, it's better not to encourage fierce competition. It seems like putting your children in competitive situations at a young age might cultivate anxiety or an unhealthy propensity for defeating others.
Diana Neameyer July 20, 2012 at 03:40 pm
Seriously??? It's not even worth the time to vote. It's a cute, fun event and it's not the toddlers who have anxiety, it's the parents. Unfortunately, it's too late to teach or train the parents to back off. Without healthy, good spirited competition we may as well just sit like a bump on a log and watch the world go by. Good competition makes us put forth that extra effort and strive to be the best we can be.
Diana Neameyer
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Heyitsme May 17, 2013 at 07:23 pm
Oh, an her dad works for Cargill, IT staff. And stop throwing out bad science regarding theRead More agricultural industry. Professionals again do NOT arbitrarily throw out these diagnosies. It was not in the food she ate. We tried food elimination/avoidance before the medication. I ate healthy while pregnant and her sister certainly doesn't have ADHD. Instead she has mild dyslexia. I guess my asthma was not genetic either. All these things are genetic, not environmentally caused. Triggers can be environmental.
Heyitsme May 17, 2013 at 07:31 pm
Can you use a mini trampoline in school? Subject your student to be called in class for acting up?Read More Schools expect the student to sit and listen. So do the best for your child and give him a helping hand if possible. I am not advocating medication unless possible...it just ticks me off that you have some people that think its just a lazy label handed out by doctors.
Heyitsme May 17, 2013 at 07:34 pm
MINE doesn't sell her medication. One it's a felony and two she NEEDS to take her medication.Read More The bottle doesn't leave the house and is locked up. It is very difficult to get a controlled substance like the ADHD medication refilled before the current prescription is scheduled to run out of pills. Too many of the "lost" refill requests can result in an investigation. She lost her pills once (only a nine doses of pills left) and I had to sign a waiver stating that the prescription was truly lost.
KCLEGACYMEDIA May 7, 2013 at 12:40 am
We just made an inforgraphic that outlines the staggering cost of prom for 2013. Check it out here:Read More http://www.kclegacypress.com/2013/05/06/closer-look-at-cost-of-prom/
Scott May 9, 2013 at 10:34 pm
Hi Mike -- It is possible to have liberal ideals and spend wisely. Sheri's son got a free tux on theRead More back of his hardworking friends? Sounds like communism to me! In all seriousness, I applaud Sheri for raising a sensible son, and I deplore Mike B.'s parents for raising him to blame a political party for all shortcomings in a society.
Mike B. May 9, 2013 at 10:39 pm
Scott, there is no such thing as "liberal ideals." Liberals are pro-abortion, pro-taxingRead More people to death, pro-homosexual marriage, pro-kicking God out of the classroom.... these are not "ideals." These are evil beliefs.